פסקי דין רבניים עדכון 2016 - 506
פסק הדין המקורינפתח באתר המקור — din.gov.il / Sefaria
טקסט מלא של הפסק ←
N JIIJIfJ/J c',"',,' 7" .M':I 1'0'''' ",,,'.:a , nm",,,, m., t"rn t:I'N , '" .nV' .n 17J/-Z476 'riDnlJfDD17'" (7171< I' 'T17D) 7"';' N 'J l'1!)1 .,,'V 1!)W' l'1vU'l'1 "l'1'''W ., W 16 , !)' 'l'1::l::l '::lnw .,'::In 'V l'1,It 'V::l'::ll'11t V::l,l'1 'It V::l,l'1 It,., .l'1v'l'., l'11t "l'10'" ' OO'v n,l'1' l'1,::l'V It'., "W V' ,"' !)::l l'1v'l' ."l'1' ' nl'1" It,." ''''vl'1 1"::l 1!)W 1t,1t ," " ::ll'1!lm l'1ac 1!lW ac,w ::l'WO '::l .C"" 90 'O' O , Oo .""l'11'" r1MO V'::ll'1' 'ac 'V "oac, Wv::lO, ,""l'11"::l 1"" l'1'::l::l m 'V 1'" 1 '0 O"J':! 7" i'0 .""l'11"::l v" 1ac V,::ll'1" ,C'O' 3 1'l'1::l1"" l'1'::l, r,no 'l'1V'::ll'1l'11t "JO, 'ac 'V 100" 1'WOW (-) 0"" Vw,." (-) ,"::lac ,1'" ::l" C.,,::lac (-) O"J':!;' 7" i'0 ,n b .n'M .n;, l'J::l ''',,'::l 'v' '::l 'v C"' !)::l P"l'1., ac,ac ,l'1,It 'V::l "V'::ll'1" l'11t , o It'W ,::l,::l 11 It, ,'It r" ::l '''!)V l'1ltl' ,::l,,'0 ::ll'1 ,,'V It'l''''' 1"" l'1'::l 'V "oac, Wv::l, ,""'!)WO , "., W,::l'W" .3269/95 7"" rn, ;, .I"m::l C,It::l '::l1M., 1" .It ''''vl'1 1" 1t,1t ," " ::lIt'W '''::In::l '::l,n .::l D',wn' - ]''1 'pU9 •"1),:1 :I"n CltM ,"1)" '''P '11' 'i'? "pM "tnM? l11'J'IU 11i'?l' .J .16 11:1 It'M'IU:l '11:1:1 M?:In ?'It' ilP':I11:1 '''P:I It'M It:lltM ClotM ., .1"M 11':1 m:l tl ,JJ:l 11'lot:l'P? ilJ'I)M .iI i1:mo1'1 ,'1!:l'''' ,.,1>S, ,i'I" ,0'"'' "C:'lm 01C:" 1')1> ,"n ,.,',n, )'1n" :, !:l ,)"n" c:'., i'''' ",C:", .lot ".,11>C::l 1.,0'n 1)'!:lf> :" "1>0 :In "0 1>"1C:' i'0!:l1 ..1:l1 1n1f>!:l') ,"n 1":l" ,"!:l" ..1:l1 nC:"1 n,c:, 1:l'!:l) ,l"f>!:l,mc: ":l" OC:1' ,C:1"!:l) ni')S f»f> 'I1n 1,'f> "11>"C ,0"" "c'"n, ,"n 1'C' "11>" .0"" "c'"n, ,"n 0' ,m" f>S'1 '11>" 1>'i'1 1,',n, )'1n" 1,',n, ),nc: o,f> ::l\ f> '!:l OC ''' '''!:l1> , "1>0 f> "0 1>"1C' i'0!:l ,o'n",,, 0"'" 1,) 1'f>c 1"""1 .1" " '1!:l'1 n,c )'f> ,'!:l1:l1 nC1'1 0 !:l1 ,1>S i'1;) )f>,c' T,f>, 0':l'''0 o,'f>c 0"'" 1" " 1'f> '!:l:l ),m" O"!:l) )'1n" 1'!:l1:l i" ,1'" 1'f> n'C1 '1!:l' f>c f>"'1 :c"f>,,, oc:, '11;)" OC, f>",,",'1 1" " p'f> )f>.,c' pf>' 0':l1"0 o,'f>C o',"'C !:l"1>f> :" "1>0 1)")' .IC"'"'' n1>') "",) 0") "f>"" )1>' O"!:lm 1") 1) 1','n" 1) '1f>,,, '11>'C 1) In'c: 11':l1 ,\;)" )1>') O"!:l'C ,1> ,1l1f> 1',m ,1l10,i' Of>1 :f>"""1 .1"" 1'f>'S1" 1'f> ,)11;)') 1) '1f>,C :m '11>'C i'r',,, O!:ln of> 1:l1 ,10"!:lm f» 1" 1," .,) 1'1>",C 1'f> ,01!:lnf> "":l ,1> 1>,f>c: 'i'1;) ') 1",C i'l'," .,,,f>' ,1> 1) "!:l:ln" 1'f> ,1n),n ,1>' 11""" 1) lmC !:l"1>f> 1,',n, )'1n" :f> "1>0 ':In "0 1>"1C' i'0!:l1 f»C ),nC:l o f>'" '1 ":l)"C 1 "1>0 , 'i'1;) ')" ,,:1 1>"1C' '01:11 .1.,1>S )1> 1) )1n,,', 1m" C:i"'C: .:1,1:l' I i'''0 f> "0 n":11Si" :1":1" 1'" 1'f>c :1" O)C) ,"n of>" ),nc :1'1" )'1n:1C::l of>:1 0',1,nf> 1i')m, n1>" "S"c: " i'''0 f> "0 0"":1 "n "1>1 ,O)C" ,,'f> of> f>1:1 1)U1 C"'S) O)C) ,"n 1"S1>' f>1'" ,n:l , "0 ""1n :1," ',,,f>1 , "!:l 10 ll1'1n:l :1f»!:l:1 "1>1 ,C"'S) ,"n """ O'i' "", '1>S1 i'm 0"'''''' ,n:l n 1l1f> 10 r:l "0 1"1>:1'f> f>"1rn, omf> ,l:l :1,1>:1 1)n ',,1» , n1f> "", nnm" ":1" , '" n"m1 ""!:l,' f>,,', ,01!:ln' "":l 1>,') ',:l ,,),n) f>",c f>" :1C1>C 01>1;)) f> '!:l ''' :1 :1:l,S1:1 1>1'" :l"f>, nnm", )"''' '' ,n:l1 .',:ll' 11') '1f>.,C ,,,,, ')1f> ,,,,) i"m:1 ),:l', 1>"C" ,1nf>'1" '!:l )1> O)C) ,"nc: :1IC f>"1rn:1 )1> :1"n f> '!:l i'''' ,nC:1n)'f>, o,,,t» n""1Si':l f»1 ,'11;)!:l' f>"1rn:1n1>" oc: )",,, "", '''' :1 )C 1,"nf>m 1"i' 1l1f> :1)i' ',,1> ,"n "1;)!:lt" n1>'"'' .t""1> ,,"n )'1n"C :1'1n, '1n:l:1 , , o',,,,f>, 1'1;)')n" ,",'c :1" '''!:l1> f»f> 1"S1>" 1>'1' 1,'f>C 1!:l1f>' f>"1rn" "" f>',,, ,l"!:l )1>1 ")1;)'" .1),m:1nf> n,"n" '''',:1 )C f>",c" 1'f>C ,1) ( Ultlaa l.:£ IlC)te:£ l.:£ j(I:£l.(j( Q.LJCj( ..ellCJC :JC U ttlClC ::\Cl::lC .ulCte 4 ulC d.wI j(:£1I.( Q":£a..e :£ttC ':t lC"I:: j(te u"..er ••I.( ,.tel( .ICI ttuj(:£ ..e:£lte lu ll.;c L..e.L I::JC l.:£ I::.JC l.:£ j(I.Lr l.:£ lled l.:£ .ICI 1..e.:£I.(:£ ttJCc II l.JC ll.;c L..e.L Il.JC QJCI:: :£I.I.(:£ .JCctt JCI ll.;c L..e.L QJC ..edI.(I:: ' tett ,ate ..elI::.a ,.L::\lC 'Ij(j(Ca ..ettl .L '..ellC.JC :£ ..ett. I I ' I;a L..eI;j( JC. JCc I:: ..ealj(c 'll.;c L..e.L IC.JC QJCI:: IJC '..ellC.JC r"lC Q..L:£te Qu:£a..e:£ JCI lcI ' j(:£I.( .a.La ..ellelC 'L..eI;j( ca.L r...lC r"lC d":£ I::,,JC..e :£ttCI ')I::,,..te QJCI ' j(:£I.( ..ellC.JC:£ .lj(tt j(:£I.(.L l.alj(l::tt :£I.I.(.L Q.JC..e. a I.(.CI I:: ld tt JC d":£ Q...elteI:: d d ••tel '::\,,::\ ,L.lCI. JCj(.L IJCj( Qll::a JCI j(:£IU :£I.I.(.L j(,,c l.(u..er ...e:£.L Qte Q.JCttal( l.alj(l::tt :£I.U Qr l.JC ..e lC.JC l.JC ')dic l::teI:: Qll::a JCj(I :£..e ..eaJC :QI:: :£ ,ar:£I '<\CI lI::. l.:£ ..ete l.:£ .L.la l.:£ rrlI:: l.:£ Qj( tej( .Ltela Q.LJC :JC C d":£ cl::a:£I '<\CI ..ellelC Q...e:£.L te:£..eJC l.ctej( :£..I.( l.dlc l.ctej( ' j(lCCI .Latel :£ ..e.c JCj(I ld.I.(:£ j( ttucla dJC tt. .C.L JC.al.L '.L.laj( :£l..ed JC .L.la:£ IJC JCj(JC Q...e:£.L te:£..eJC .:£..l.(a JCj(.L JC"te ,LIlC C d":£ ."I::..e:£ atele ,.tel 1j(.lCJC :£..I.( tt:£I::1 .IlC...e ..ete;.L JC".I :r:£ ,.telC JCctt ,.lC teulI:::£1 'tt:£I::1 .IlC...e :£.ttC Qtt .L 'Q.I::CJC ll:£...e. rrlI:: l.:£ Qj(ltej( .Lte a Q.LJC.L :£..I.( dIC:£ j(:£JC '.L.laj( :£l..ed rrlI:: JCj(JC lC CJC . . JCj(I:: .L:£j(:£1 CIIC:£ JCj(I:: 'lI::. l.:£ ..ete l.:£ .L.la:£ l.:£ j(c rrlI:::£ ,LJC j(:£U .a.L:£ :£..U aua 'll.;c L..e.L JCC lJCc tt. JCj( lI::. IJC rrlI:: ttl. :£I:: lC"teJC.L j(,,;I 'll.;c L..e.L :£I::UC . .L.la:£ . QJCI:: JCC. .JC .IlC..e JCj(:£1 'lttla.Ldj( ..e IU•• lC...e ."tel:: '.IlC...e L...e;I:: ::\ca 1:£ j(te QJC r d"lC al:: ,.lC a" ttc:£ :£ttC 'r JCj( JClC..ett. JCj(I:: ll'I j(C.L l .c '.IlC...e Qj(l::j( d.la L...e;I:: Q..Lla te"IC.L JC..ec 'j(j(C ttla.Ldj( ..ellUj( ..el::lCJC Qlda:£ JCj(JC .IlC...e:£ :£..U IC.JCI:: :£ttC JCj( lled ,.lC d":£ .c.L..ea ,LJCI 'JCI ..e.L JCj(.L JCI::UC 'lttla.Ldj( ..ellU. j(:£JC '.IlC..e:£ :£..U ru c Q.LJC:£.L '..ellUj( ..e a••IlC..e •utel ':£ctett.I:: d..e lttla.Ldj( ..ellUj( j(IC••IlC..e JCj(:£ ,LJCI:: :£..IUa d.la j(c.L 'JClCI..e ..eCI:::£ :£..U d.la '..ellUttI:: JC. j(IC. JClCI..e .ute d..e a;tea JC..e.L JCj(I::C j(Ij(.LIC .JC.L JC::\.L ....earj( CttI::C JCj(I:: ,LJC ldI. ..eC.CI:: j(c ' CII::JC..e:£ JCI I:: ttlac . .I:: dlc ..e.IU j( j(j(c:£ I II:: '.L tt JC r. ,.lC d":£ JCullUI '. d"lC IlCI:: ,.lC uu l;d ,.tel 'la;tea j(j(c JClC..ett. JCj(I::C ltt..e.ca:£ 'dic j(j(c:£ JCj(I .IlC...e I:£I.U llaa .dic ..eJCI:::£.L 'llaa .dic ..eJCl::a ttlj(:£U l..L dlj(u dlC:£.L :Culle ,j( .lj( Q..U IC.:£..e ,.u:£ :£ttCI QJC.L '.L.lClC::\I:: Ic aa .lC.j(U Q I:: 'l.alj(l::tt:£ :£..uttaI:: JCI I :£I.U ttaual 'I.L.lClC I:: la;te llaa JC ttj(utt 'tt j(:£u:£ cuJCl::a 'l.alj(l::tt :£I.U Qr .j(te j(..u I JCj( .L.lClC I:: llaa ..ed.te:£ :£..utta . JCj( ttI::I:£1 ..ete;.L JC:£I.UC 'ttlj(:£U.L cu lra dlc .11.1:: ttaua ..eltt ltt:£..U.L 'Qa;te l.alj(l::tt:£ JCI I:£ .U lc lell::lC ..e:£.L Q":£a..e ttte.L .lCj(.L ttaJC:£I ',ICI I:£I.U ttj(utt JCI l.alj(l::tt :£I.U.L dlC.L JC:£ .U Qr lc ttU lC IC.JCI:: dic dI ',ICI Q...euJC j(I:: cled tt;£;£ j(:£IU :j(ul .Lu. d.lal j(:£IU ,j( a .LulC:£ dlClCI:: lacI Q'';>\!ln' - 1" 'j7t> , CC '''!:I' 1:l' ,":l ::l'!:I0:l" ::l'rm!:lfJ fJ" 'lfJ i''' ,,'n fJ:l'fJ, '''0' ',::l ,''':l .::l'C fJ,::l ',::l ::l!:lO:l" ,::l" .''':l .ni"S fJ'fJ 'I1n "'fJ " ::lC C"" ::lc'"n, ,"n ,'C, " ,, ::l" C:l "on "'!:IfJ :'''1 '''::l fJ:l" "::l i"I::lC ::l"" ,1'''''Cn::l' i" fJ,::l ",'n I'l,'nm fJI"C!:I ',::l ::l'!:I0:l" ::l'nn!:lfJ fJ" i''' .(::l'!:I0:l" ::l'l'ln!:lfJ fJ,' i''' ,,'n 1:l1'l' ,'fJ n"' ::l , ::l"nc CC fJ",m ''''' " " '\:l' ":l 1'"'' 'O!:l::l ,,'n::l 'i" 1'"'' 'i''''' n!:li' ''' , II' ''' , ::l ''' fJ"Tl i'''' C"' 'C m"'c,, "", ,fJ" ,'m::l' 'i" ::l"n, "fJ ,::l,m::l::l C'i'''' C::l 1'''''CI'l::lC fJ'fJ ,1,tfJ'::l "S", "O!:l::lt j!:ln::l mm::l fJ'::l ':l' cfJl'l::l' ,'lU::l '!:I',n m,I'l' fJ" ,1'"'' ,,'n fJ'fJ ,1,tfJ'::l "S", "m::l 'lu I'l,m::l "'fJ fJ,::l ,,'n::l ,,,n, l'''''tl'l::l ,,'nt n"' ::l 'l'0,::l, , ,t" 1'"'' I'lSi'''' ::l,'''' "tn ::l"n I'lSi'''' ::l""t ,,, ,i'r, ::lt t c,t" fJ" '1'0" fJ,' 'fJ'::l C't" ,::lt t ::l"' ::l ::lt '" fJ" ::l m c, fJ'::l ,"n"::l "S", i"I::lt fJ5!:1n::l I'lfJ ,'m::l' ,,"n, l'fJ t" ,, ,O'i' 1" ::l11 ,C,, m'n" fJ,::l '''nc 1'''''::l' ::l"", ::l"m i'r,c ::l"!:I ,,,n "::l C"''''::l nl"t" ':l' ::l'fJ,' ,C" ::l C::l c'm::l ,,,,,cm ,1'CfJ'::l "n c,'o', t,, "fJ ',::l ,,,n '''''tm p'm ,"I'!:I i'm O'i" ::l,'''' ,1'"'' fJ" o'i' ',::lI'lC,,' , S, l'fJ ,,',n, "m" (160 ''' l "'::l I"" 1'" "n '!:IO 'l,o,t c',n:l'" I"' " .:l" .1'"'' "n fJ" O'i' .'!:I\:l l' :l ',::l' ,i'''::l ,"',tl'l' ,,"n, :l"::lU fJ'fJ ,fJ""", fJ"" 'O!:l::l C'C" ":l ",'n 'i" ,,'n i" ,"!:I',::l ,,'c I'lfJ " c,t, 1'"'' "n "'fJ "!:I'" 'I'l:l n', l'l,fJ m"l'l:l C"' C j"i" "fJ ::l:lf ,,, p',,,fJ fJ,' ,"c,,', c'c, ",S l'fJ ",m::l '::l' :l"nfJ' ',Il'" ,,,n::l ,"nm cfJ, ,,mfJll" ::l" l'l'fJ, 'i',SI' '" 'l'l,fJ!:I" ,,,n::l' "I'l' ,,,'t fJ'fJ 1'"'' m:lf 11 l'fJ' ,'l'lfJ,ll, ,,,,, "m::l 'O!:l::l 1'l,,'C::l fJ'::l i"fT.I::l ,,'n cfJ:I 'i'nt C"C' :I" ,t ''' ,"n ::l",t I'l" l":lf '!:IO " , .,, ''', .'Oll,t '"S jlln::ll'l"'t::l fJ,::l ",'nc ,fJ ,i'""C jlln::l ,,,, " , ,',Il',::l lm, ::l" C ',,:l ,fJ i''':;' 1"13 :;,, c ',,:l cfJ:;, ,"!:I":;' , c'c, ,"n :;":;" :;',,:l 1'" t', ,,'n fJ,::l cfJ, ,'''':;' :;"'i'n, '"m fJ",m:;, cc, :;':li' ''' (fJ"I"'C 'I'm, "n, :;, fJ"',' "c"n '"n" I'l t:l c'c, ,"nl'l' ,1I'l,fJll" 1" ,,:;, 'fJ "fJ ,:;",n:l :;,t "I'l t ,, '!:I:l "Il":;' '''''CI'l' ,"n 1'"'' c, "0 n"::l'Si" ,fJ "0 1"''' 'i''' fJ"m" ,, ,1'"'' 'i''' 1" ' c'mnfJ:;, :;'13 ", ,,,, .' '!:I' "!:I":;' 'fJi'm' 1,m, ,'1' mfJ n "0 i'''' fJ"'m' ,fJ i'''0 ,'t "0 I'!:IC" "", , ":;' "Il m":lC t",fJ, ,fJ i'''0 ,I'oi' ''' , ,,:l C"C", ,"O!:l' ""n:;, i"1l C', i'''' C"' 'C '0'I'''i'' ,i"":;' :;'''' ''':;' "Il i'''' . :ll'l ''' n "" ,n c-I C ''' I "" l",,,fJ ,,, ,'''' ::l"n c"nfJ ,t ::l,I'i' 1'l33 ,,,n:;, "" '1 ,fJ ", :;""" fJ , :fJ I!:I i'''' ''' , ., fJ"" ,fJ ,::l1l0:l" :;'l'lnllfJ fJ::l, 1'''" ,":;' :;,,,fJ, 'm :;",n ,'fJ, C"' ' n,c fJmn, :;'" "i'fJ, 1":l , , 'fJ' l":l :;",n "fJ ,'0" 'S"l'nt :;':l1", ::l' '0"'" , , 'fJ, fJ,,,n, :;'" "i'fJ, fJ,:;, C"' ' n,c ."" C"' ' n,c fJ'fJ ,fJ, :;"1I'l :;'I'l:lf fJ' '''fJ .fJ,,,Tl" :I" :;''''i' fJ' ,,',n 'S" fJ' :;" "nn" ;, nll1nn :l£1o:m :lmfll'l!'l1£1:l i''' ofl o'"mfl ,t :l'''i' I'l" ,,,I1:l :, "l'O ,:m "0 l'",t, i'0£1, ..", :l"'I'l'fl I'lt", "£1''1' '1l'S "fl ,:l"fl ,t :ll'l'1"" 110" :l'" :ltl''' ''1:lt "fl ,t :ll'l,t p' I,fl:l ,t fl':l ''1:l .'"l' .:l,t fl':l ''1:l :l£1O,,, :l1'l!'l1D :l,'flt i''' 1" 1:l,t .:l"' :lt '1nfl, 1,t ,,, ,:l'''i' :In':lt' :ll'SD't 11" ,t "D''1 ,,,, l'"n, '''l)' ,fl:l 1'fll"'D' .!'l1"'i''' :l"'" ," '''l' fl 1'1' o',t,'1' '''OD "l) .:"1 -I'" ::l" Cl:"l'::ll't ::l " O'i' '1"" ,,,, l',m:lt "'1£1" ,:It,, 1'l'1'I'l' " 0''1'" "", ,mfl,'1l" l"'I'l' " '1,ofl, fl':l ,,'tD :l':l, '1''1' ,,'fl' ,t :l':l' lD,fl, O"D' 1'D"t fl:l' ,fl"'Ir>:l' fl",fl '"''1 :l'' 11":l13 "£1''1 0'" fl" ''1:l :l"fl", .,fl, fl" :li'""t I'l,:l, "'I1:l ''1:l ,'O"D' 11'" ,,,,,, :l':l't :lfl'1' fl, ,""" "'1i' !'l11'l'" '1''1' ,,'fl :l"fl" "", .1"'t :l'" .I":l" I'" I'll'''l'l :l,'fl fl':l' I,fl:l' fl" I'l" 1"t "£1''1:l .:l13 l'"5, ,"£1''1 '1,.1, :l,:lI'li"S i"0, l"'I'l' "fl ,fl, ,fl t"" .\.I,t :l':l ofl 1'" 1''15 ,I'l,:l I'l"'" '1tD' ofl 0.1' ",t£1 '1,,:l 'i"l''' ." "0' '1fl"" "", 1l'l"l O,t 1'fll'l,fl,'1l" _ICO"l 1'r&1ClU