פסקי דין רבניים עדכון 2016 - 514

N UL[LlClC lc.-Z;S1£,aaumaad,u C .?/ ,C :t..:.I L Jl,lC:t:.I LJIt'lllC 'lC c..:.I .?/ :.1:t,.?/,:t lCu..C LJI...lL:t'lI ..L:t'lI ..C.?/ 'l1:tLJI ,N :t..:.I J1 ,JlJllC ..:tC.?/ N N 'lC, .?/L.., ...l'll NlC( JIL'lI,ot .IL'lIL .?/...lLJl t.soos- :.I...?/:.I ..C.?/ L ...lJlN:t ' L.lt CLCO L :t"Jll"...1'l1 ,:;'JlL C"Jlt.?/ L.?/lC:tL 'N lCW ..C.?/W JIN L C ....n N :.I.ILC'lIW CW :.I,W N LN 'C"LJl...l c,a,:;," L lJlt '.?/N..lC c,a,:;, :ta ,:t :t..WlC .?/...I IN c..w.?/ C,lC'lIGW ,LO,C L C .?/ CL, C,lC..LJI L W,W, CN.?/ .?/L..,G:t L ..lCNL ':.IIC ..C.?/ L :t"JlJl:.l.?/ .?/,JlClC lC :t..:.I N .?/ :.llC C .?/ :t"Jl Lt,NL .:.I:;,...?/ ,GC L C .?/ ,:t.?/:t JILlCL..JI L L,W N W.?/'lIlC L 'm:;,..c JIN W LJIL WI:t :.I.ILlC ,N :t..:.IL ':.I:t,.?/, 'l1,tw C,lC'lIG :.1:t..:.1 ..JlNlC W,:.I ,N :t..w.?/ I'lILlC ,:t :t..w 'L JllC:tL:.I.?/ ,GC ..C.?/:.I CL .?/JI ,N:t :.11 :.I.ILlC IN :t..:.I 'C.ILa 'l1,.IL:.I , ClC :.lt.?/:.I 'l1:;'lCNC :.I.ILC'lI:.I JIN CI'lI IN C..:.I.?/ ,:t c..:.II'lILlC .IL'lI '..lCLGlCC LlC:;''lI :.IN....C.?/ :t,a N .?/ lL,clC.?/ I'lILlC LN ':.11:t lC! IrC , • c' \!Jn' - )', 'pun 1"" n,, ro;, ."O' "l'1 ":"1' ON" 'NJl'1 ,..., , "nl'1:"1 ON :"I 'W' "'..., , W •" V :"I ...,W O'v'l' vlm .T I V' :"I"" ,nN W "­ .1'1 'v' :"IV":"I N"""" :"IJW:"I Vl' N :"I" V:"I l'1N IVW '" ;, n 1"C ll"l.lfl 1""" o,fl '" 1"l'mc 1'fl",,, ):l :J' "l.l0 ,., "Ol.l"'C' ,,,,, fl"'ll ""':l" 0"'"'''' 'I'l:l 1) "'i'fl fl) "Cl.ll'l fl) ofl ,fl "'''' fl) ofl' ,"'" 1) 11'lfl 1:l "Cl.ll'l ofl ,fl 1:l "'''' ofl ""C" 0" 'I'll.l, ,.,"c ,"'i'''' .,m fl) "'''' ofl .,,,,fl,, ):lC ,"'i' fl) .",,, "'''C ,fl "Cl.lC ll"l.lfl ,1) 11'lfll I'lfl "m" fl), )l.l1ll .,:lC ofl" "'i' fl) 'fl, ):l , '0 ""33 ''''i'''' .,,'''' fl) fl"c ,fl "'''' fl"c 1'l:lT. (' i'''0 """m,, " i'''0 1l""'Si'" fl"., "0 """m, 1l""'Si' 'i')!l' ,.,,, ,'fl,1'l "',:l )1ll:l 'flm, .,:l """m, ,1l""'Si' :l":l ,)",m fl) "Cl.l"" 'fl,I'l" o"i' fl) oflc fl)fl ,"'I'l"C ''':l O"i') ll":ll.l ''''11'' .(fl,,)l.l' ')'" '",,,,l) ,mfl 1"'CIl ,fl,1'l )ll:l fl) ofl, '''lll.l fl "l.l0 ,,)C "Ol.l"'C' fl",,"," i'oll ,.,,, ,l.l,m" ml.l":l ,)l.l1ll) '''''l.l' '''1111'' fl) ofl OJ 0': fl) 1'" .,Ilfl), .", o'c ,) .", fl), '" ",,) '''''l.l' ,) .,,,flc ,,,),, 0""""" oc, ,"C "0 ,,", ':l,' 1')'J.,C ''':l "l.l" 1" ,., 1" ,,,)C 1"''' 'll) ,) 11'l') 1'''S ,O'):l ,) .", fl)c )'fl'" .", o'c ,) 11'l') 1'l"'C, :l":l' .mc." fl)c '''''11 ,,'c 1'1'l) ,.",,, l.l.,J fl), ,'Il'l'" .,:lC ,) ':ll.l) 1'fl' .,Ilfl O'i'''' 11 ):lC l.l"I'l" 1"fl., Ol.l 1"" .,:lC l.l"m 1'l.l"C )C ,mm) o'''i' 1"fl., fl"" oflc ":li' "0 '''11 fl",c' m'" ,) fl',,,, m'Il" )l.l' Il:lfl)'" '" i'0l.l1'l" 1:l I'll.l, )l.lC lC''''ll:l 1"1'l0 1:l' m',m" ')l.l, ,J:;' 'll m"I'l" 1""" :l":l' .C.,lll" 'flm:l fl,,, ,.,,, 01'l0 0""" 0'" U"'C :;,,, 0'"'' ):l, ,mi''' l'l,t , "l.l0 '0., "Ol.l"'C' fl"".,,, i'0!l1 .1":l"i' "'I'l" OC) fl) '''''Ill'lfl ",,,,,"c fl",c"" oc, "", , 1'1'l"'S fl), )'fl,,, ""l.l I'l'Cl.l 0"11' .,,,,) '''''11 ):l" fl) """ ,fl ")'l.lll '''''11 Ol.l "C'l.lC o,fl ): .mc ,) 11'l') 1'''S t> ,,'c l.l", ')'llflmc." '''''11 ,,'C) ,.",,, :, "l.l0 "l.lC "Ol.l"'C' '"'' '''ll ","fl' ,,)'rJ 0"'"'''' i'0 ofl' "ns,,,,, )"" Il'C" )l.l ""'I'l' "flS'"" "I'l':;' oflc ,""')l.l" )l.l "" ,) 1'''C ,l.l"') ""Cl.l ""t m.,,,) ""')l.l" )l.l "" 1l"C") O)C) '''11 "'C,, )l.l'C C.,lll" .1l'C" )"" "flS'"" )l.l "I'l' Il,t ummc 'e"u cI:: ,GC Q\I::\ ,"UI:: Q.cG\ L..e l.y QI\I:: \te l::Y.ea lac,lC I\,YI:: 'QI\I::Zt \te l::y.ea lac,lC Y\I:: GlC C \te e,.LI:: e "a a"IU , c YG ,,ll::e , c 'I::!ee eI:: caa .e I, ceel ,./.eI,C ,lCIC QY QCay y"u l"e,./.ec ,,ll::e e c .eC:CI:: y\y 'CCI,\teC \te I"/,I:: !e\IU l,y I::!ee eI:: ca \te \'y ' II::.e, Y\I:: ,./.eI,C 'Cl::teI:: ,eG\ lc I::.e,G Y\I:: ll,c Cl::teI:: IGlCICC I"/letec \te ale .eCI:: I::I.e,./\ \IC, \telGC l,yI:: .e "a l y \te Ic al IC.e1"/ \'!eI:: ll,c ,eyl:: l"',./.eC \1:: c.e!eacI:: YlC!e ,ate C L.ec Q,\I::I.e, "/,,aG' "te Ly ,eGa I\\C cy\ac y ll::te,I:: Q,.euy Q,\telG y la ',,Cte' C,C l::y.ea .eCI:: te'lZt C,C I\,YI I"/I'te C,C y\ ',,Cte'l le al lel.eI"/ lc,\te Q,\'!ea Y\I:: Ztlcy\a Cl::lte C,C QY \'y 'lca Ll::aeI:: Zt\tel C lc I::.e,G Y\I:: G"tey .eCI:: lc,\te tel'Zt\ \MCC ,yCI '.eCI:: Y\' I\Y Icy\a 1\ ll::te,I:: Q,.euy y la 'c\,UZta !e, e !e,IUa QY a"GCI 'lalllC' QI\I:: C IY QI\I::Zt Zty.elCC IC,"/ QY Q,!elCIGC 1!e\UC !e, \1:: 1.e"/ \te 'C Ic,y !e,q !e,IUaCI:: Q,.eI'ac Q,!ealGCa I::, 'Y\I:: ,ate y, L.ec Q,\I::I.e, ,./,,aG "tel 'QI\I::Zt' !elUlac IC,"/ I::, Ly 'ZtteC QI\I::Zt C I.eI:: CI YlC 1.e"ua y, lacI '!ec,\ QI\I:: Zty.elC' y\y la te lc:CC !e,IUac !elUla y.e!ec !e,q !elUlac C"tel 'y allC,a l,"/a acc IC,"/I ',"c.eaa .elCl::a 'IlC .eZtl, !e, I:: Q,.eI'ac U, ,ate " la\ZtI::C c,acG ZtlC.e!e, ,,.ec ZtC!e ,, lC.elCCI!e1 ,./c ,ate U L.ec Q,\I::I.e, "/,,lCG "tel ' a:cc !e,q CCI!eC Q\,I:: QY l,"/c ca \,, l ',I::,\y I::,,,.e c l.ea Zty )I"lCI:: ,.eI::Zt ,./ QI,e( ,Zt\YI::I '\,,"/.e c QI::, l a IY CYI\C .elUC l,cte\I l.eZty' ,,QC\" l,cte\ Q\,I::I:: eI::Uc Qyc '!eeeca I IY C,./G y\ .eclac G"tey Q\,I::I:: eI::Uc .ecla\ Q\,I::I:: lana a:ccI:: QI::CI 'lalla acc 'I::UC !e, I:: l.ea e,I::CI 'c!e"/ 'C"te '!e,q Lc ' lc:CC l::a I::C y\ .ec acI:: ,./, yZt YlC QI\I:: C y.e c \'!ea I' 'l,G,\u .elCI:: YlC !e, )y(LE "telC Ztl.elCI::C "/I!eG' !elUC ,G\ ( LalCac .eaac y\ "/lte \C ccaa .ellU\ lZt,e ca\I:: cc,y \'!ea\ .elCI::C .e,lCa IY(ZO "telC ,G\ ',y!ec, !e, I:: lyca ',ycZt y\\ Ztl,C\ CC,.e QI\I::ZtC Zt,./I!eG '871 'LE 'E Q,G,telC ,G\I '\te G , CZtll::te\ a"te Q"!eZtC ,./tela\ ,./te 'Q,./!ela ,CI ,U ,ycZt, ,e lac ,,./, te I'U Q,!ec\ "./C lIulC'\ \,!ea\ .eaacI:: 86 ,ate lC,!e.eC - " I.elCI:: ,c,,./" cy.e( 1.ealI::C 'I::Ue .elCI::C !e,IUal ' ,.elCI::C I'UC YG!ela ,yc c ')9ZW88 y"tea l.ea QI::, 'e IY cte ',,lCGl::aC .ey," .eGlCC IlC' "CC\C' !e, c" lC.elCc !ee , C '.eulYa !e,qI:: y\y Q,GlCC .el::teac ll'I::Ua I:CC\ QCIte.eG lal MC' c"uy C I.e c!e"/ \ Q"IU"/ Q,!e, l c QyI:: y"I::,.e c ,I::U\ c"uy \IC, .e,GI::I 'y"/,.e 'IU .elCI::C ',I::U lalc ,eG\ lCCC I' \ \IC, Ic,yI:: ll,c 'lY ',,U CI:: 'C"te '1,,te .el::teac 1\ I,C, Qy,,, ,C la C ,C y\ ,y ,.eC I::.e,./I:: .eCI::C \te I',,U CCI:: ,./la\\ l ,c I\\C Q,!e, ca QCay LI::.e,./I:: QIClCC \te Q,!e, 1\ l cI 1\ , C L,y ',yc ' C ,C llI:: 1 CtC\CC QyI:: 'uQ,a.e1 D"7lDll' - 1" 'PU 1"m1'" 1'1:1 I'mp "J'01 fJm1fJ1 fJll'" fJ'l1C 'i""J' '''Ji'P fJ,"J "JpfJ :, fJ:I '"'1 fJ "i' p", 'P ' .J 'l' "0 01C"J 1"'''J 11"1C' '11:1' .1:l 1""'l'1 1'''J11,p:I "J,:l fJ" fJ,'o, ,:1 fJ11"p, fJ":I ,'m 1""'l" ,o,cp :l'''J fJ :l', '11'p, 'l"'''' 0"'11'1 :lfJ"J1 ,'l1fJ "111fJ1 "i'1 "J'O 'fJ'1 '":ll" 1i"'0 fJ' ofJ, .("111fJ 1C "0 "111'1C11:l "JS1fJ", fJ'1:l) C""l' ,"J 11' :lfJ"J'C lP! "JllfJ :lfJ'1fJp p'"" "'i'1 "J'O 'fJ'1,1 ,1'''J111'fJ 'l' 11"0:1 :ll"'11 'fJ '''J:l 11fJ 11ll'C' l"11 " '''J:lC 1'l'PC fJ' 1'" 11"'31 "J1'l' "'l'p, o'C' '''11 :l",P:l :lm ", ,11p'i'1p :ll"1:l fJ" l'SpfJ, :l"'l':l 11fJ "DC "'l' ., l'SpfJ, '1"l1p P""J fJ,Sp, 1'fJc ,:l,'C', P""J 'C :l"Ji'P' .0'C'11 :lC1'C 'C "J:lC 11mi'1p :ll"':l 'fJ :l':l ofJ 1p:I ,:l'C:l '110' 'l' 1"J111,C 0'C'111:l ,:1 11fJ "1l':l 11fJ '''11' c' ,:l'10 11fJ"Ji" fJ'fJ :l,C:l 'Pl' " 1"J:I 0',C1"J' '''0' "D) 11p'i'1p :ll"1:l fJ" :l'C:l l'SpfJ, p""J:l 11fJ "J"" "'l'P:l ofJ 1":l, .(1p"J p"p ," l1,,":lC :lP ,:1 11fJ "i' fJ,c 1:1' "'l'P:l '''l' "J,,1'p ,pSl' :lfJ"JC 1l'1" "1l':lC 0 :l1 :l'C:l '110' "'l'P:l 11fJ l"'" :l':l "'l':l 'l'1 ,1' :l':l'C:I, '111:l 11fJ , , fJ'fJ ,1:1 "J'O fJ' "'l'P:l .'1',l1p p""J fJSp'c ',:1 :l'1'l':l 11fJ '1Il" ''''l' fJ1:lC •T11' ::11' C:"I'::IM ::I lfJ:I "J':lP ,,'fJ .0"l'1':l "" ,:1:1 'l'1' 1" lfJ:I c' fJ'fJ 1'''J' 1 '''J1' "", ":ll" :l' 1'''JS fJ' ,'11l'" O'C, 11l" 'l' '''J' 'fJ'1" ,(:ll 1" 11" 11 :I ,111'1pp, o"'S," o',",p 1111) 0"11' "'l'C 'p 1"JfJ' ."J:lC"i'" .l'1'i' 1'''JfJ11' '''1111:l' '1:1' 1,'fJC O':I'''JfJ11, :l'11:1:l ,",'11C'" i'''J fJ1:lC [" 1'pfJ'1] "JpfJc '1fJ1 :ll ,:1, .1111' :l':l fJ' '''111p :l':l fJ' OfJ1 ,0""11l' O'i"S 1, 111' 0 1 lp!:lP i"11 'l' l' O,'CC ""J"1 ., .11111':l 1:lp .fJ :"J"J" C'1 ,0"l""C 11111':1 l' l" P '11l'" 1:1'1 ."'l'P1 "1l' '011' 'l' :lfJ"JP P11' ,800S i'''J :l"cfJ"J:l :l'C, '1,,1C 1"fJ, "i' ofJ . .11"J1:1CP, ",:1 fJ,t'lC 1fJ 111l"O' O"'i'P ofJt'l '110 'l' "J"'11t'lC lP!t'l 'l' o l' l" P ,:l"l1p 1'fJc 1'1fJ, ., .1,'fJ1 t'l"C:l :l'C:lP :l"l1p lfJ:I C'C fJ,t'l lP! 11"1111' 'l' "J,,'11t'lC t'l'1i'11t'l 'l'1 .1P! ,:1 11"1111' 111"JpCp '11"11 C' 111"C" ':I ,"1pI" 1111fJ lP" 11"JllfJ t'll'St'l l' t'l11':l fJ' ofJ "J"J" 1'''JS "fJ .t'll"O'3 m" fJ' o '''Jt'l, ,'''' 'l',,:I l' l" P '1fJc :l'1,l' ,1"" fJ'fJ ,"J,,1,p:l1'" IfJp :l'1'l' 'fJ'11 11l'''Jt'l [i'''J] lfJ:I 1'fJc 01Cp t'l! ,:1, .,,,'1p t'l't'lC .1l"J1:1CP ", '1,l" ' 10p fJ' 'l1fJ ."'":"1 I;'"C